A very hard fought, very tough scenario for both sides. The Germans grabbed the initiative and the advantage by quickly occupying town hexes on both maps. They got these positions reinforced as the French attacked en masse and gave the Germans a really hard scrap. The Germans had the advantage in the assault as they were able to pull armor in to the fight. The French pushed the German right hard, and almost took the sunken railway. But, the Germans were able to pull more reinforcements from their left and used their own armored reinforcements to contain the counterattack. The Germans held more town hexes and railway hexes in the end, a hard, hard german win.