Americans set up in a semi-circle a few hexes from 2728. The Germans split up and approached from the north and south. A few turns in the Germans got lucky and achieved four consecutive attacks where the Americans took step losses. The remaining US troops fell back and took further casualties. The GI's held on for a while longer, but eventually the Germans overwhelmed them for a major victory. This scenario wasn't close, but the Germans got extremely lucky in this one. I could see it being a lot closer.